Johnson v. Davis: the legal basis
Johnson v. Davis, 480 So. 2d 625 (Fla. 1985), of the Florida Supreme Court, establishes that the seller has an affirmative duty to disclose any known material fact affecting the property's value, not reasonably observable by the buyer.
Three criteria:
- Seller knows the fact.
- The fact affects value.
- The fact is not reasonably observable by buyer during a tour.
If all three are met and seller failed to disclose, buyer has a fraud civil remedy.
Standard SPDS content
The Florida Realtors form covers:
- Roof: age, past leaks, repairs, active warranty.
- Plumbing: type (polybutylene?), leaks, water heater.
- Electrical: panel brand, amperage, known issues.
- HVAC: age, maintenance, operation.
- Structure: cracks, settling, infiltration.
- Hurricane damage: Andrew, Wilma, Irma, Ian, Helene, Milton, etc.
- Flooding: past events, flood zone, NFIP claim history.
- Termites & WDO: presence, treatment, warranty.
- Septic & well: if applicable, last pumping, water quality.
- Chinese drywall: 2001–2008 homes.
- Asbestos, lead, radon, mold: known presence.
- HOA / condo: pending litigation, special assessments.
- Liens, judgments, litigation on the property.
- Open permits.
- Wood-destroying organisms inspection history.
- Sinkholes: past events, repairs.
How to read an SPDS
- Read every "Yes" box carefully. Request details on all yes.
- Verify "No" with skepticism on at-risk items (hurricane damage in hurricane zone = very unlikely no).
- For each "Unknown", ask why seller doesn't know (recent buyer? inheritance?).
- Cross-reference with county property appraiser history and permit search.
- Keep written copy of SPDS in your files — legal evidence post-sale.
Answers that should raise alarms
- "No, but I'm not sure" = diplomatic cover, request specifics.
- Hurricane damage: "No" on a property in hurricane zone that went through Andrew/Irma/Ian/Helene/Milton = unlikely.
- Roof leaks: "No, repaired" without documentation of repairs = signal for deeper roof inspection.
- HOA litigation: "No" when major special assessment is pending = potential lie.
- Permit history: "None" when an addition is clearly visible = possible lie.
- "Don't know" on questions a normal owner would know (e.g., water heater age).
Remedies if hidden defect post-sale
If after closing you discover a material defect the seller knew about and failed to disclose:
- Document the defect with photos, repair quotes, expert if possible.
- Show seller's knowledge: prior repair invoices, neighbor testimony, before-after photos.
- Demand letter via FL attorney.
- Mediation (often required pre-trial in FL).
- Civil fraud lawsuit (Johnson v. Davis) if mediation fails.
Statute of limitations: FL fraud = 4 years from discovery (Florida Statutes §95.11).
Comparison with Quebec DV
| Aspect | Quebec (DV) | Florida (SPDS) |
|---|---|---|
| Mandatory | Yes (OACIQ) | Not by statute, but by Johnson v. Davis |
| Format | Standardized OACIQ form | Standardized Florida Realtors form (most common) |
| Coverage | Hidden defects, infiltration, pyrite, serpula, etc. | Same + hurricane, termites, Chinese drywall, sinkholes |
| AS-IS | No direct equivalent; sale without warranty possible but rare | AS-IS common; seller discloses but doesn't repair |
| Fraud remedy | Hidden defects Civil Code + damages | Johnson v. Davis fraud claim |
| Prescription | 3 years (hidden defects) | 4 years (FL fraud) from discovery |
Every figure, rate, threshold, and deadline in this guide is drawn from a verifiable primary source listed at the bottom of the page. The article is updated whenever the underlying rules change, with a fresh review date stamped at the top.
Sources and references
All sources were publicly accessible at the last review date. Figures and rules may change; verify the current version before any decision.
- Johnson v. Davis, 480 So. 2d 625 (Fla. 1985) — Seller's duty to disclose. scholar.google.com
- Florida Realtors — Seller's Property Disclosure Statement form. floridarealtors.org
- Florida Statutes §95.11 — Statute of limitations for fraud. flsenate.gov/§95.11
- OACIQ Déclaration du vendeur (DV). oaciq.com
- Code civil du Québec art. 1726 — vices cachés.
You've completed Topic 01.5
Inspection and due diligence covered. Next: Topic 01.6 on title and closing.